Meghann Fahy's journey sounds like a dream. She moved to New York City at age 18 to understudy the role of Natalie in tragic Broadway musical Next to Normal, ultimately playing the troubled, neglected teen for her own run until the show's close in 2011. That open call, by the way, had been her first ever audition. Before completing that gig, she made her first of 81 appearances on ABC's One Life to Live, in which her character Hannah stalked an ex-boyfriend and overdosed on painkillers.