VIDEO : Danielle Campbell Picks Her Favorite One Direction Song

It's a question for the ages: Which single from One Direction's Midnight Memories album is better, "Best Song Ever" or "Story of My Life?" The Originals star Danielle Campbell , who is dating 1D member Louis Tomlinson, settled the debate when she sat down with E! News to play the hard-hitting game "Would You Rather?" After picking "Best Song Ever" as the best 1D single, the actress, who plays powerful witch Davina Clare on the CW's Friday night supernatural show, also takes sides on divisive issues like: still water or sparkling water? Vampire or werewolf? The Originals airs Friday nights at 9 p.m. on The CW.